GEN
Active topics
  1. Originally posted by kharbouch:my ranking depends on my annual state of my mind

    1 - 1987 : The Joshua Tree
    2 - 1991 : Achtung Baby
    3 - 1983 : War
    4 - 1997 : Pop
    5 - 1980 : Boy
    6 - 1988 : Rattle And Hum
    7 - 2000 : All That You Can't Leave Behind
    8 - 2004 : How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb
    9 - 2009 : No Line On The Horizon
    10 - 2017 : Songs of Experience
    11 - 1981 : October
    12 - 1984 : The Unforgettable Fire
    13 - 1993 : Zooropa
    14 - 2014 : Songs of Innocence
    Zooropa @ 13??
  3. Originally posted by LikeASong:[..]
    We should grade all of them separately (after purchasing them in as many coloured editions as possible, obviously - that will help the band make more money gradings to be as precise as possible) and do a weighted average with the following formula

    16 tracks edition x 17.2%
    +
    17 tracks edition x 18.3%
    +
    20 tracks edition x 21.5%
    +
    40 tracks edition x 43.0%

    Add the cassette edition for further accuracy in the calculations.


    And yet it still makes sense to include it in a ranking of albums?! 😂
  4. I was just joking with the %s and stuff, but yes - the 40 song version (which is the "main album" in this whole madness) shall be included in the rankings.
  5. Achtung Baby
    Joshua Tree
    Unforgettable Fire
    Pop
    Zooropa
    Songs of Experience
    No Line on the Horizon
    Boy
    All That You Can't Leave Behind
    War
    Rattle and Hum
    October
    How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb
    Songs of Innocence

    This is actually too hard. The only ones I'm personally set on are the top three and the bottom three. After that, and ever after, I haven't had a clue.