I've got the same beef with the 1981-11-14 - Boston, Massachusetts show. Sounds like a 4-star bootleg to me, not the 5 stars it's given on the download page. Thanks!
for a soundboard it is good though. Against Dublin R.D.S it may not be as good but for what it is I thinks it's a very good recording. Maybe we shoulf start rating recordings based on type rather than overall sound. If someone doesn't like soundboards thay are rarely gonna score them 5/5.
Or add a HC (High Category) for some shows. There are hardly any shows who can match the sound of RDS, South Bend and Sarajevo...
all of which are broadcasts and not soundboards though. Broadcasts are typically better than anything else but that shouldn't mean excellent soundboards or audience recordings shouldn't get credited. I think we should rate soundboards and audiences sepereately. Sure Saitama 3 isn't as good as RDS but it's still a 4.5/5 audience recording. Sames with DC 1992, it's terrible compared to RDS but it's still an awesome 5/5 soundborad.
all of which are broadcasts and not soundboards though. Broadcasts are typically better than anything else but that shouldn't mean excellent soundboards or audience recordings shouldn't get credited. I think we should rate soundboards and audiences sepereately. Sure Saitama 3 isn't as good as RDS but it's still a 4.5/5 audience recording. Sames with DC 1992, it's terrible compared to RDS but it's still an awesome soundborad.
all of which are broadcasts and not soundboards though. Broadcasts are typically better than anything else but that shouldn't mean excellent soundboards or audience recordings shouldn't get credited. I think we should rate soundboards and audiences sepereately. Sure Saitama 3 isn't as good as RDS but it's still a 4.5/5 audience recording. Sames with DC 1992, it's terrible compared to RDS but it's still an awesome 5/5 soundborad.
I see what you're saying, but I disagree. When I first stumbled across this site, I started downloading all the 5 star shows. I had no clue what IEMs where, or the difference between a matrix and a soundboard. I just liked that there was an easy star-rating system and I could work my way through the best of the best. While I originally started with just the 5-stars, I quickly moved into 4 stars and even have some 3 stars on my computer now.
In my opinion, 5 stars should be reserved for the best of the best shows: RDS, Red Rocks, South Bend, the Point Depot shows, Buenos Aires Vertigo, etc. (that's a well-rounded list that includes broadcast, audience and soundboards).
And there's no shame in a 4 star show. There's some real gems in that category too. (And yes, I've warmed up to DC ZooTV since the BRT. It should definitely be a 4 or 4.5)
I see what you're saying, but I disagree. When I first stumbled across this site, I started downloading all the 5 star shows. I had no clue what IEMs where, or the difference between a matrix and a soundboard. I just liked that there was an easy star-rating system and I could work my way through the best of the best. While I originally started with just the 5-stars, I quickly moved into 4 stars and even have some 3 stars on my computer now.
In my opinion, 5 stars should be reserved for the best of the best shows: RDS, Red Rocks, South Bend, the Point Depot shows, Buenos Aires Vertigo, etc. (that's a well-rounded list that includes broadcast, audience and soundboards).
And there's no shame in a 4 star show. There's some real gems in that category too. (And yes, I've warmed up to DC ZooTV since the BRT. It should definitely be a 4 or 4.5)
I agree and disagree at the same time. The ratings on the site are still far from perfect. But if we take RDS as 5 star then there are not an awful lot more 5 star recordings about. Saitama 3 has to be a 4.5 but RDS is more than half a point better. You see the confliction. I want all good recordings to get their deserved ratings and not to be marked down because a few pro recorded broadcasts are just so awesomely good .
did you know? U2 is the richest band in the world.
latest site news Jeremy, known as haytrain here, is the latest addition to the U2start crew. Jeremy will be a crew member specialised in bootlegs, he will mainly work on maintaining our bootleg collection, making it even better, more r.. (read more)
new fan around us The most recent fan who registered is named rein, welcome to U2start rein! As a new user you can introduce yourself in the Welcome to U2start y'all forum.
popular songs Where The Streets Have No Name is the most-requested song from the song pages and quite popular. According to the favorite song lists of our users, Bad is the all-time favorite song.
news headlines We cover the news of many international U2 websites including U2.com, the most popular headline in the last two weeks was 'U2 fans queue in mysterious ways' from atu2.com.
popular concerts According to our user reviews, 1987-07-08 - Brussels, Belgium is the best bootleg we have in our collection. Our users also think that 1993-08-28 - Dublin, Ireland was a great concert since it appears the most in the list of favorite concerts.
statistics There are currently 4,713 topics started on the forums with over 205,199 messages.
More than 13,105 fans are a member of U2start. The average age of the U2start users is 29, only users who submitted their age are included in this figure.
fan of the month Every month we put an U2 fan in the spotlights, the fan of this month is user Ali709. Every fan of the month has an interview with us, you can read our interview with Ali709 here.
bootleg of the month Every month we have a bootleg in the spotlights, the current one took place on 2005-05-18 in East Rutherford, New Jersey. You can download this bootleg, read reviews or write your own review here. You can also join the discussion on this bootleg in our forums.
high resolution photos We have 696 high resolution U2 photos available for you, the biggest photo collection you will find. The latest photo we've added is 'October'.
"Am i a massive shagger? Of course, just ask the wife."
- Bono in Q Magazine, 2005
