Language: English  Help: FAQ and info    
Welcome to U2start.com!
Create a free account here or log in here.
 forum info
 statistics
 bookmarks
 subscriptions
 mark all forums read
 search in forums
 active forum topics
 topics you posted in

Report incorrect ratings here!

This topic was started on 2007-01-09 07:42 pm.
There are 325 messages contributed to this topic.
    Return to the topics list
  Open a new topic in this forum
  Post a reply to this topic


  Report this topic to a crew member
     Forums » Upgrades and additions
«  previous   3  4  5  6  7    next  »
Open new topic   |   Post a reply    
posted by Remy (Webmaster) on 2007-02-08 08:46 pm quote

Originally posted by zooTV4all:
[..]

Thats ok, but Dublin 1989-12-31 is as we all know a radio broadcast, so why not 5 stars??

Copenhagen 2005-07-31 for example, has fantastic sound, excellent, but it's in fact not a soundboard, as listed here. The sound there is a lot better than Stockholm soundboard 1992-06-11. I mean, you dont want to mislead people by telling them bootlegs are soundboards, but its a very THIN line here, dont you think??

I am bugging you? Don't mean to bug ya.


You're right about Copenhagen, I'll change the rating from that bootleg.

And I don't know about Dublin #4, the audience recording is pretty similar to the radio broadcast. I don't actually know which one it is here, but I'll change it to 5.

posted by LikeASong (Crew member) on 2007-02-23 05:17 pm quote

2001-05-03 Clevelaand, it's an Ex.SBD!

posted by Remy (Webmaster) on 2007-02-23 05:34 pm quote

Originally posted by LikeASong:
2001-05-03 Clevelaand, it's an Ex.SBD!


Already changed, you're just a minute too late

posted by colbourne25 (Member) on 2007-02-24 04:11 am quote

i really think milan II should be 4 stars not 3... great sound and performance and the crowd to go with it... simply stunning

posted by Remy (Webmaster) on 2007-02-24 11:46 am quote

Originally posted by colbourne25:
i really think milan II should be 4 stars not 3... great sound and performance and the crowd to go with it... simply stunning


No, it's nothing more than 3 stars compared to the 'real' excellent audience recordings. There are dozens of better recordings available which are worth 4 stars.

posted by zooTV4all (Member) on 2007-02-24 01:18 pm quote


1984-10-23 - Nantes, France - St. Herblain

At least my bootleg of this is sbd.

posted by Remy (Webmaster) on 2007-02-24 01:45 pm quote

Originally posted by zooTV4all:

1984-10-23 - Nantes, France - St. Herblain

At least my bootleg of this is sbd.


Mine isn't, or if it is, it's a really bad soundboard which deserves nothing more than 4 stars.
Could you upload one track for me to compare?

posted by zooTV4all (Member) on 2007-02-24 03:19 pm quote

Originally posted by Remy:
[..]

Mine isn't, or if it is, it's a really bad soundboard which deserves nothing more than 4 stars.
Could you upload one track for me to compare?



Well, does not make any sense to me. I thought soundboard was rated 5 stars here no matter of the quality. Otherwise should excellent audience recordings like Copenhagen 2005-07-31 or Dublin 1989-12-26 be rated 5 stars too.

Anyway, here is Bad from Nantes:

Please login or register to view this link


posted by Remy (Webmaster) on 2007-02-24 03:49 pm quote

Originally posted by zooTV4all:
[..]


Well, does not make any sense to me. I thought soundboard was rated 5 stars here no matter of the quality. Otherwise should excellent audience recordings like Copenhagen 2005-07-31 or Dublin 1989-12-26 be rated 5 stars too.

Anyway, here is Bad from Nantes:

Please login or register to view this link



You're right, but there are always exceptions I'll give your Bad a listen.

posted by Remy (Webmaster) on 2007-02-24 03:53 pm quote

The source is the same but in my copy there's also some audience mixed through it.

posted by LikeASong (Crew member) on 2007-02-25 04:08 pm quote

There are soundboards which deserves 3 stars (yes, 3!) and audience recordings which deserves 5 or more, if you could. That's quite subjective.

I think each concert could have his own calification, not 5 califications for all. Remy, this is for you
Thanks, C·U

posted by Remy (Webmaster) on 2007-02-25 04:14 pm quote

Originally posted by LikeASong:
There are soundboards which deserves 3 stars (yes, 3!) and audience recordings which deserves 5 or more, if you could. That's quite subjective.

I think each concert could have his own calification, not 5 califications for all. Remy, this is for you
Thanks, C·U


The ratings are very questionable sometimes, I totally understand that, this is the best in a while that I can offer y'all

     Forums » Upgrades and additions
«  previous   3  4  5  6  7    next  »
Open new topic   |   Post a reply    

 


Previous
  • fan of the month
    Every month we put an U2 fan in the spotlights, the fan of this month is user Ali709. Every fan of the month has an interview with us, you can read our interview with Ali709 here.
  • bootleg of the month
    Every month we have a bootleg in the spotlights, the current one took place on 2005-05-18 in East Rutherford, New Jersey. You can download this bootleg, read reviews or write your own review here. You can also join the discussion on this bootleg in our forums.
  • popular songs
    Where The Streets Have No Name is the most-requested song from the song pages and quite popular. According to the favorite song lists of our users, Bad is the all-time favorite song.
  • audio and video bootlegs
    U2start has the biggest U2 audio and video bootleg collection. The latest bootleg we added is 2005-09-17 - Toronto, Ontario . The latest video bootleg is Bologna, Italy - Stadio Comunale.
  • notable live performance
    A great performance of Trip Through Your Wires from the The Joshua Tree album was played in Rosemont, Illinois on 1987-10-28, according to user ozootv.
  • new fan around us
    The most recent fan who registered is named qui, welcome to U2start qui! As a new user you can introduce yourself in the Welcome to U2start y'all forum.
  • popular concerts
    According to our user reviews, 1987-07-08 - Brussels, Belgium is the best bootleg we have in our collection. Our users also think that 1993-08-28 - Dublin, Ireland was a great concert since it appears the most in the list of favorite concerts.
  • high resolution photos
    We have 696 high resolution U2 photos available for you, the biggest photo collection you will find. The latest photo we've added is 'October'.
  • latest site news
    Jeremy, known as haytrain here, is the latest addition to the U2start crew. Jeremy will be a crew member specialised in bootlegs, he will mainly work on maintaining our bootleg collection, making it even better, more r.. (read more)
  • did you know?
    The album Pop is named so because for U2 it was a tribute to popular music, art and culture.
  • news headlines
    We cover the news of many international U2 websites including U2.com, the most popular headline in the last two weeks was 'U2 fans queue in mysterious ways' from atu2.com.
  • statistics
    There are currently 4,712 topics started on the forums with over 205,190 messages. More than 13,101 fans are a member of U2start. The average age of the U2start users is 29, only users who submitted their age are included in this figure.
Next


 
"It amazes me when people tell me they played it at their wedding or for comfort at a funeral. I go to myself, 'Are you crazy? It's about breaking up.'" Bono, 2004, about the song 'One'
 
Make a donation © U2start.com v3.0 (2006-2008) RSS feeds
U2start is a succesfull remy.tv production from the Netherlands.U2start is not affiliated with U2, their management company, their record label or any related bodies. All content are copyright their respective owners.