Thats ok, but Dublin 1989-12-31 is as we all know a radio broadcast, so why not 5 stars??
Copenhagen 2005-07-31 for example, has fantastic sound, excellent, but it's in fact not a soundboard, as listed here. The sound there is a lot better than Stockholm soundboard 1992-06-11. I mean, you dont want to mislead people by telling them bootlegs are soundboards, but its a very THIN line here, dont you think??
I am bugging you? Don't mean to bug ya.
You're right about Copenhagen, I'll change the rating from that bootleg.
And I don't know about Dublin #4, the audience recording is pretty similar to the radio broadcast. I don't actually know which one it is here, but I'll change it to 5.
2001-05-03 Clevelaand, it's an Ex.SBD!
Originally posted by LikeASong:
2001-05-03 Clevelaand, it's an Ex.SBD!
Already changed, you're just a minute too late
i really think milan II should be 4 stars not 3... great sound and performance and the crowd to go with it... simply stunning
Originally posted by colbourne25:
i really think milan II should be 4 stars not 3... great sound and performance and the crowd to go with it... simply stunning
No, it's nothing more than 3 stars compared to the 'real' excellent audience recordings. There are dozens of better recordings available which are worth 4 stars.
1984-10-23 - Nantes, France - St. Herblain
At least my bootleg of this is sbd.
Originally posted by zooTV4all:
1984-10-23 - Nantes, France - St. Herblain
At least my bootleg of this is sbd.
Mine isn't, or if it is, it's a really bad soundboard which deserves nothing more than 4 stars.
Could you upload one track for me to compare?
Originally posted by Remy:
[..]
Mine isn't, or if it is, it's a really bad soundboard which deserves nothing more than 4 stars.
Could you upload one track for me to compare?
Well, does not make any sense to me. I thought soundboard was rated 5 stars here no matter of the quality. Otherwise should excellent audience recordings like Copenhagen 2005-07-31 or Dublin 1989-12-26 be rated 5 stars too.
Well, does not make any sense to me. I thought soundboard was rated 5 stars here no matter of the quality. Otherwise should excellent audience recordings like Copenhagen 2005-07-31 or Dublin 1989-12-26 be rated 5 stars too.
EN
