Originally posted by WojBhoy:

Croke Park 24-06-2005, I'm thinking 2 stars is a bit harsh, 2.5 maybe? That said, I'm not certain how the ratings go exactly - is this a 192kps boot or not?

Originally posted by aussiemofo:

Just wondering whether any thought's been given to reviewing the ratings of all the shows that U2want has uploaded recently. That Austin 22/11/1987 boot, in particular is superb. With the exception of a few distortions around the start and One Tree Hill it's near perfect IMO. It could push for a higher rating than the 4/5 that's been given here. Just a thought anyway.

Originally posted by RDB92:

1992-05-22 - Milan This one has very solid sound, I can't see why it shouldn't be 4 stars. Not any higher than that, it's not very special, but it deserves 4 stars. 1997-05-16 - Clemson Every member of the band is clearly audible as well as the crowd, there is just some very slight distortion. But it deserves more than 2 stars, I think 3.5 stars would do it justice.

Originally posted by Remy:

[..] Made it 4 and 3, thanks!

Originally posted by germcevoy:

[..] milan isnt a 4. We all decided on this on thn brt. Its too muffled.

Originally posted by Remy:

[..] Check the bootleg reviews on that page, every member gives 4 stars to the sound quality.. Except you

Originally posted by germcevoy:

[..] they are all clearly wrong then. Listen yourself. Way to muffled. Paris a week or 2 earlier is a 4. Hear the difference

Originally posted by dieder:

1993-11-16 - Adelaide, Australia - Football Park (video) It's not as bad as a 3-star recording should be in my opinion. Sound is pretty clear and the image is not that bad...