|
|
germcevoy
God Part II
Posts: 13205
Location: Ireland - Song of The Week : Heartland
|
check 1987-07-08 LikeASong and give me your opinion. I think it's a 4 but I want a second opinion. Definatley a 3.5 at least
|
|
ReclinerMan
Boy-Girl
Posts: 275
Location: The Western Air Temple
|
Some rating changes to give with the brand new rating system:
Please login or register to view this link = 3.5 stars (audience recording of performance is clear but age has not been kind to the source material)
Please login or register to view this link = 4.5 stars (soundboard recording of performance is clear but the mix has terrible audience to band ratio; the sampler material sometimes overpowers the band's playing i.e. Where the Streets Have No Name)
With the Bootleg Round Table and my listening of bootlegs all over the site, I hope to be helpful in updating the bootleg information in all of its glory. 
|
|
Remy
Mirrorball Man
Posts: 5320
Location: Holland
|
Originally posted by ReclinerMan:
Some rating changes to give with the brand new rating system:
Please login or register to view this link = 3.5 stars (audience recording of performance is clear but age has not been kind to the source material)
Please login or register to view this link = 4.5 stars (soundboard recording of performance is clear but the mix has terrible audience to band ratio; the sampler material sometimes overpowers the band's playing i.e. Where the Streets Have No Name)
With the Bootleg Round Table and my listening of bootlegs all over the site, I hope to be helpful in updating the bootleg information in all of its glory.
|
Both changed. Also changed the type recording from audience to soundboard on the Isreal bootleg.
|
|
LikeASong
The Wanderer
Posts: 8345
Location: Madrid, Spain............YES WE CAN...!!!
|
Originally posted by germcevoy:
|
check 1987-07-08 LikeASong and give me your opinion. I think it's a 4 but I want a second opinion. Definatley a 3.5 at least
|
4 stars would be OK, yep.
Remy, what about that?
Originally posted by LikeASong:
|
And the same goes to 1987-10-20 Iowa. Very good Audience if you ask me (3 or 3,5 stars).
|
Originally posted by LikeASong:
|
Don't downloaded at all, but I heard that 1987-12-08 Atlanta had a great sound. Check it out!
|
|
|
Remy
Mirrorball Man
Posts: 5320
Location: Holland
|
Originally posted by LikeASong:
[..]4 stars would be OK, yep.
Remy, what about that?
|
If you two agree, then you won't need me 
|
|
LikeASong
The Wanderer
Posts: 8345
Location: Madrid, Spain............YES WE CAN...!!!
|
Originally posted by Remy:
|
[If you two agree, then you won't need me
|
No no sorry I posted before adding the Quotes. We're misunderstanding! Check out the bootlegs I told you.
|
|
stefano1973
Sweetest Thing
Posts: 559
Location: Milan, Italy
|
1992-04-20 Tacoma
This is reported as 3 stars but the sound is quite poor, I dont think it deserves more than 2 stars to be good 
|
|
Remy
Mirrorball Man
Posts: 5320
Location: Holland
|
Originally posted by stefano1973:
1992-04-20 Tacoma
This is reported as 3 stars but the sound is quite poor, I dont think it deserves more than 2 stars to be good
|
Indeed, very crappy recording. Gave it 1,5 star. Thanks!
|
|
Remy
Mirrorball Man
Posts: 5320
Location: Holland
|
Originally posted by LikeASong:
[..]4 stars would be OK, yep.
Remy, what about that?[..][..]
|
3.5 is okay, there's a hiss in my recording that prevents it from the 4 stars.
|
|
Remy
Mirrorball Man
Posts: 5320
Location: Holland
|
Originally posted by LikeASong:
And the same goes to 1987-10-20 Iowa. Very good Audience if you ask me (3 or 3,5 stars).
|
Make it 3, there's some annoying scratching sound popping up sometimes during the songs.
|
|
Remy
Mirrorball Man
Posts: 5320
Location: Holland
|
Originally posted by LikeASong:
Don't downloaded at all, but I heard that 1987-12-08 Atlanta had a great sound. Check it out!
|
Well, seems like half of the songs are 1 star, and the other half is 4 stars.
Weird recording.
|
|
germcevoy
God Part II
Posts: 13205
Location: Ireland - Song of The Week : Heartland
|
Originally posted by Remy:
[..]
Well, seems like half of the songs are 1 star, and the other half is 4 stars.
Weird recording.
|
probably the taper changing position. Its like that on one of the Vertigo Sydney shows. The first 3 songs are 1.5 and the rest is 4 for the same reason
|
|
|
|
