home       bootlegs       more audio       videos       songs       photos       forums     Language: English  Help: FAQ and info    
Welcome at U2start.com!
Create a free account here or log in here.
 forum info
 statistics
 bookmarks
 subscriptions
 mark all forums read
 search in forums
 active forum topics
 topics you posted in

Report incorrect ratings here!

This topic was started on 2007-01-09 07:42 pm.
There are 313 messages contributed to this topic.
    Return to the topics list
  Open a new topic in this forum
  Post a reply to this topic


  Report this topic to a crew member
     Forums » Upgrades and additions
2  3  4  5    next  »
Open new topic   |   Post a reply    
posted by Remy (Webmaster) on 2007-01-09 07:42 pm quote

If you see a bootleg with too many or too less stars, please report it here so we can update it.

First, make sure you:
- Talk about the same show as uploaded here, if you have a 5-star soundboard recording and there's a 2 star audience recording uploaded, your new rating doesn't apply here!
- Rate the sound quality of the recording, a soundboard can also receive 2 stars if it's really bad!
- We realise that a sound rating is personal, so please only report a new rating if you think we're very wrong here.

You can suggest new ratings from 1 to 5 stars, half stars are possible too!

And make sure you mention the date and the location of the bootleg of you can copy/paste the URL of the bootleg here.

A crew member will verify your input as soon as possible!

posted by alfmlc (Member) on 2007-01-09 09:11 pm quote

2001-10-10 - Elevation live in South Bend
The sound is not good... especially the last songs.
My rating is 3 or max 4 stars.

posted by matsimon (Member) on 2007-01-09 09:20 pm quote

zoo tv wembley first night: 4 stars! very good soundboard!

posted by Remy (Webmaster) on 2007-01-09 09:30 pm quote

Originally posted by alfmlc:
2001-10-10 - Elevation live in South Bend
The sound is not good... especially the last songs.
My rating is 3 or max 4 stars.


Weird, my copy is a soundboard. I'll just upload my copy then

posted by Remy (Webmaster) on 2007-01-09 09:30 pm quote

Originally posted by matsimon:
zoo tv wembley first night: 4 stars! very good soundboard!


Soundboards are 5 stars Thanks!

posted by LikeASong (Site manager) on 2007-01-26 06:28 pm quote

1992-09-13 Madison - It's an Excellent Sounboard, not a Good Aud.
1992-05-09 Gent - It's an Very Good /Excellent Audience (4 stars!).
1987-06-28 Dublin - It's a Very Good / Very Good + Audience (3 stars).
I will post more in a while!

posted by Remy (Webmaster) on 2007-01-26 07:24 pm quote

Originally posted by LikeASong:
1992-09-13 Madison - It's an Excellent Sounboard, not a Good Aud.
1992-05-09 Gent - It's an Very Good /Excellent Audience (4 stars!).
1987-06-28 Dublin - It's a Very Good / Very Good + Audience (3 stars).
I will post more in a while!


Thanks!! All changed!

posted by LikeASong (Site manager) on 2007-01-26 09:24 pm quote

MEGAPOST of incorrect ratings!!!!!!!

1984-11-06 Glasgow - it's a ex. audience, 4 stars.
1985-03-27 Montreal - excellent soundboard, 5 stars.
1983-02-26 Dundee - very good audience, 3,5 stars (you decide if 3 or 4).
1983-07-02 Torhout - excellent soundboard!! 5 stars!!!
1983-08-20 St. Goarshausen - excellent soundboard, officially released show!! 7 stars!
1992-04-23 Vancouver - excellent audience, 4 stars (if we could set 5 stars for audience recordings, this how would have them!)
1992-05-22 Milan - great audience!! 5 stars, please!!! If not, 4 stars and a commentary below saying it's the best audience recording of the Zoo TV!!!!!
1992-06-04 Dortmund - excellent aud., 4 stars!!
1992-06-05 Dortmund - the same as 06-04.
1992-06-08 Gothemburgh - the same, 4 stars.
1992-06-15 Rotterdam - very good soundboard, not 5 stars, I think it has a 8/10, you decide if 4 or 5.
1992-03-05 Atlanta - excellent audience plus! 4 stars!!
1992-04-21 Tacoma - excellent audience, 4 stars.
1992-08-22 Foxboro - excellent recording, 4 stars.
1993-05-10 Rotterdam - excellent audience, 4 stars (if not 5 )!!!!
1993-06-04 Munich - ex. aud, 4 stars.
1993-06-12 Cologne - great audience, there are two copies of this gig, one is Good Aud. and the other one is Ex. Aud. Remy, you uploaded the show, you know which version did you upload!
1993-06-15 Berlin - exactly the same comment as Cologne.
1993-06-26 Paris - excellent audience, 4 stars.
1993-07-03 Veroan - an awesome recording, excellent audience, 4 stars.
1993-08-07 Glasgow - you uploaded it, I think it deserves 4 stars!!!
1993-08-08 Glasgow - this is a high quality recording...clearly 4 stars!
1993-08-12 London - great soundboard; 5 stars. Nothing else to say!
1993-12-10 Tokio - excellent audience, clearly 4 stars!
1989-12-01 Osaka - excellent audience, 4 stars.
1989-12-18 Amsterdamm - Excellent audience!!! 4 Stars!!!!
1989-12-26 Dublin - Remy, why did you get 4 stars to this show? It's a great soundboard! 5 stars, please!
1989-12-27 Dublin
1984-11-06 Glasgow - it's a ex. audience, 4 stars.
1985-03-27 Montreal - excellent soundboard, 5 stars.
1983-02-26 Dundee - very good audience, 3,5 stars (you decide if 3 or 4).
1987-04-20 L.A. - excellent audience, not 3 stars! 4!!
1987-04-21 L.A. - that's a very good / excellent audience, I think the rating of 1 star is from the oldest version! 4 stars, please!!
1987-04-29 Rosemont - It's one of the most popular recordings of U2! 5 stars!! I don't know if it's a soundboard or a great audience, but it's 5 stars!!!
1987-10-26 Kansas - excellent audience, 4 stars now!
1987-11-14 Oakladn - ex. audience also, Asso is a bit wrong . 4 stars.
1987-11-15 Oakland - the same, 4 stars.
1987-12-08 Atlanta - excellent audience, 4 stars! Not one
1997-04-25 Las Vegas - excellent soundboard, five stars instead one.
1997-04-28 San Diego - excellent audience, 4 stars.
1997-06-01 East Ruth. - earpiece, 5 stars soundboard.
2001-03-26 Miami - 5 stars, great recording.
2001-03-29 Charlotte - I don't know which version is uploaded here, but I have an excellent soundboard from this show, so...five stars if it is!
2001-06-02 Albany - great audience, 4 stars!!!
2001-07-10 Stockholm - great audience, 4,5 stars...
2001-12-02 Miami - excellent soundboard / or excellent audience, there are differents recordings, have the earpiece, so...5 stars!
2001-08-08 Barcelona - excellent audience >> 4 stars , great concert, recommended!

That's all folks (at least for today!!) !!!




posted by Remy (Webmaster) on 2007-01-26 09:57 pm quote

I only rate bootlegs 5 stars if it are recordings from the soundboard desk, radio broadcasts, DVD rips or television sourced bootlegs. Bootlegs like 1989-12-26 are really good but technically not a soundboard, so 4 stars is good I do not want to mislead people by telling them bootlegs are soundboard which are actually excellent of very excellent audience recordings.

Thanks for your great effort and additions! I will see when I have time for it

posted by Remy (Webmaster) on 2007-01-26 11:37 pm quote

I marked all the bootlegs I already edited, when I'm done I restore your post, excuse me

Though some comment I can't understand, like:
1993-12-10 Tokio - excellent audience, clearly 4 stars
Excellent audience?! My recording is really crap, it's not anything more than 3 stars, and that is already much. Maybe you have a better source?

1992-05-22 Milan - great audience!! 5 stars, please!!!
I have a recording (it's a good one, agree) with some annoying sounds all the way through it, you have a better one? Mine would be 3 stars.

1993-06-12 Cologne - great audience, there are two copies of this gig, one is Good Aud. and the other one is Ex. Aud. Remy, you uploaded the show, you know which version did you upload!
I definitely don't have the 4 star recording, do you have?

posted by zooTV4all (Member) on 2007-01-27 12:18 am quote


2005-11-02 - Los Angeles, California

Soundboard??? Dont think so.

posted by Remy (Webmaster) on 2007-01-27 12:21 am quote

Originally posted by zooTV4all:

2005-11-02 - Los Angeles, California

Soundboard??? Dont think so.


Indeed, not more than 2, the rating was confused with the various date of that date. Thanks!

     Forums » Upgrades and additions
2  3  4  5    next  »
Open new topic   |   Post a reply    

 

 
© U2start.com v2.6 (2006-2008)
U2start is a succesfull remy.tv production from the Netherlands.U2start is not affiliated with U2, their management company, their record label or any related bodies. All content are copyright their respective owners.