|
|
MWSAH
Popmartian
Posts: 4371
Location: Faraway and So Close! Song of the Week: 11 O'Clock Tick Tock
|
Originally posted by WojBhoy:
[..]
Am I one of the few who doesn't like the alternate version then lol? I prefer the album version because the whole song sounds more complete, I mean the chord changes sound "nicer" to me and add to the song, whereas the alternate version just sounds a bit empty in that respect...
Personal preference obviously 
|
Yep, you're the only one...I suggest we ban you!
|
|
WojBhoy
Native Son
Posts: 3347
Location: Middle of sodding nowhere in the UK... /// Actual status - I'm still looking /// Song of the moment: Until The End Of The World /// General Chat is the place for one-off questions, keep it that way!
|
Originally posted by MWSAH:
[..]
Yep, you're the only one...I suggest we ban you!
|
Well, I guess that's an option...lol
|
|
SalvationTambourine
Boy-Girl
Posts: 310
Location: Greystones, Ireland
|
i prefer the album version 2.(please dont kill me:p)
|
|
WojBhoy
Native Son
Posts: 3347
Location: Middle of sodding nowhere in the UK... /// Actual status - I'm still looking /// Song of the moment: Until The End Of The World /// General Chat is the place for one-off questions, keep it that way!
|
Originally posted by SalvationTambourine:
i prefer the album version 2.(please dont kill me:p)
|
We must stand together! lol
|
|
SalvationTambourine
Boy-Girl
Posts: 310
Location: Greystones, Ireland
|
Originally posted by WojBhoy:
[..]
We must stand together! lol
|
lol. yep. i agree with what you've already said. the alternate version is just a bit empty for me.
|
|
WojBhoy
Native Son
Posts: 3347
Location: Middle of sodding nowhere in the UK... /// Actual status - I'm still looking /// Song of the moment: Until The End Of The World /// General Chat is the place for one-off questions, keep it that way!
|
Originally posted by SalvationTambourine:
[..]
lol. yep. i agree with what you've already said. the alternate version is just a bit empty for me.
|
|
|
|
|
thefly07
Party Girl
Posts: 1087
Location: Charlotte, NC, USA
|
Originally posted by roxrios:
[..]
I agree as well!!
I just heard both versions back to back.
I have to say if I were to choose I would choose Alternate version as well, I do like the drumming and the dfferent lyrics.
But really I enjoy all versions of this track!!!
  
|
I love all versions too, and I mostly listen to the album version, but when I hear the alternate is always a nice alternative, the album version fits in well with the album. the alternate obviously fits in with the album that would have included Native Son, the early ABOY version, both of which are good songs, however I can't understand why they would have thought the early version of Sometimes was decent, that is the one track from the sessions I just can't listen to. It's good as a work in progress, but when you read that they actually thought it was done?? Hard for me to believe
|
|
roxrios
Boy-Girl
Posts: 376
Location: El Paso, Tx
|
Originally posted by thefly07:
[..]
I love all versions too, and I mostly listen to the album version, but when I hear the alternate is always a nice alternative, the album version fits in well with the album. the alternate obviously fits in with the album that would have included Native Son, the early ABOY version, both of which are good songs, however I can't understand why they would have thought the early version of Sometimes was decent, that is the one track from the sessions I just can't listen to. It's good as a work in progress, but when you read that they actually thought it was done?? Hard for me to believe
|
True, True!!
I think the album version does fit well with the album as a whole.
I like the album version of Sometimes ... It just is seems more refind, but I do like the lyrics in the alternate version.
I think Sometimes had been going through quite a transformation since 2001. It's an amazing song as well!!
|
|
Ali709
Wild Honey
Posts: 2294
Location: Tehran, Iran // AS: SCA(RED)
|
Originally posted by WojBhoy:
[..]
We must stand together! lol
|
I'm with you guys...they can't ban you now! The alternate sounds weird to me...tho nothing compares to the live version for me!
|
|
thefly07
Party Girl
Posts: 1087
Location: Charlotte, NC, USA
|
Originally posted by roxrios:
[..]
True, True!!
I think the album version does fit well with the album as a whole.
I like the album version of Sometimes ... It just is seems more refind, but I do like the lyrics in the alternate version.
I think Sometimes had been going through quite a transformation since 2001. It's an amazing song as well!!
|
all the way
|
|
djrlewis
Mirrorball Man
Posts: 5557
Location: Van Diemens Land // Actual Status: Contemplative....// Song of the Moment: Lemon (Live Sydney)
|
Originally posted by WojBhoy:
[..]
We must stand together! lol
|
Prefer the album version too 
|
|
|
|
